Analyst optimism bias and corporate R&D investment: An empirical study based on conflicts of interest and transparency of information

Analyst optimism bias and corporate R&D investment: An empirical study based on conflicts of interest and transparency of information


Author:Zhu Dong, Xin Zhang Journal:Science Research Management Date:2022,43(07)

Abstract: Innovation is the primary driving force behind development In the current period, China's scientific and technological innovation has become the focus of world attention Faced with the squeeze and competition from the " First Group" countries such as the United States, Japan and European countries, the construction of an innovative country has entered a decisive stageAs a basic guarantee for the continuous development of innovation activities, RD investment is essential to promote corporate innovationIn 2017, the intensity of China's RD expenditure ( ratio to GDP) reached 2.15% , but there was still a gap compared with the level of 2.5% 4% in major developed countries In recent years, how to increase RD investment has attracted extensive attention from the academic community

We focus on the impact of analysts as information intermediaries in the capital market on RD investment of enterprisesAlthough analysts can reduce the degree of information asymmetry between company and outside, they will also increase the pressure on short-term performance goals of company According to the information interpretation mechanism, analysts rely on their professional information collection, processing, and analysis capabilities to communicate the intrinsic value of the company through profit forecasting and rating reports, reducing the information asymmetry between external investors and the company, and alleviating the company's financing constraints and entrusted agency issues, thereby increasing the company's RD investment and promoting corporate innovation; according to the performance pressure mechanism, the analyst's job content is to predict and evaluate the short-term performance of the company, which will cause performance pressure on managers, and due to concerns about their reputation, wealth, and career development, managers will reduce long-term innovation investment in order to pursue short term performance goals, reduce corporate RD investment, and inhibit corporate innovation Therefore, the existing literature on the impact of analysts on corporate RD innovation has not yet reached a consensus conclusionIn addition, existing studies have shown that analysts' predictions are generally biased by optimism, subject to conflicts of interest such as underwriting business, increasing commission income, and maintaining customer relationships

Based on this, this paper studies the impact of analyst optimism bias on corporate RD investment, the role of conflicts of interest in it, and the role of corporate information transparency Specifically, this paper selects A -share listed companies with RD expenditures in Shanghai and Shenzhen in 2007 -2017 as a sample to empirically test the relationship between analyst optimism bias and corporate RD investment, and further examine the impact of the " conflict of interest" of analysts and corporate information transparency on this relationship The research results show that:(1) the analyst's optimistic bias is significantly negatively correlated with the company's RD investment, indicating that the analyst's optimistic bias will inhibit the company's RD investment;(2) the higher the institutional investor's shareholding ratio, the company's refinancingThe more significant the negative relationship between analyst optimism bias and corporate RD investment, indicating that the " conflict of interest" will aggravate this relationship;(3) the improvement of corporate information transparency can alleviate the negative effects of analyst optimism bias on corporate RD investment This paper further adopts methods such as changing the measurement of analyst attention and analyst optimism bias, selecting a first-order difference model to eliminate possible endogenousness of the model, and defining refinancing behavior only as equity refinancing behavior and changing the measurement of information transparency as robustness tests, and the above robustness tests still support the conclusions of this paper

From a theoretical point of view, this paper enriches and expands the research on the economic consequences of analysts ' optimistic bias and the factors of corporate RD investment; examines their impact on corporate RD investment from the perspective of analysts' optimistic bias, and identifies specific mechanisms and deepen the impact of analysts' research on corporate innovation activities; and aiming at the negative impact of analysts' optimistic bias on corporate RD investment, it further explores the role of " conflicts of interest" faced by analysts and the role of transparency of informationIt adds new evidence to the study of analysts' " conflicts of interest" and corporate information transparencySome studies have shown that in China's capital market, the information interpretation mechanism plays a leading role in analysts' attention to the impact on enterprise innovationAs a whole, analysts' attention can promote enterprise innovationThe research in this paper finds that analyst optimism bias will have a further effect on corporate innovationAnalyst optimism bias will strengthen the impact of performance pressure mechanism and weaken the effectiveness of the information interpretation mechanism, and generally have a negative impact on corporate RD investmentThis paper expands the research scope of the impact of analysts on corporate innovationThe existing literature usually limits the research object to the number of analysts who track companies This paper further tests the influence of optimistic bias in analysts' earnings forecast, and theoretically deepens the understanding of information interpretation mechanism and performance pressure mechanism Most of the previous studies focused on the influencing factors of analysts' optimistic biasIn recent years, scholars began to pay attention to its economic consequences There have been studies on the risk of stock price collapse, enterprise merger and acquisition, etc In this paper, analysts' optimistic bias is further related to enterprise RD investment, thus enriching the research on the economic consequences of analysts' optimistic bias In terms of application value, this paper suggests that the supervisory layer needs to further strengthen the isolator system, at the same time strengthen the education of analysts' professional ethics, improve the professionalism of analysts, ensure the independence and objectivity of analysts, and give full play to analysts as information intermediaries in capital marketIn addition, enterprises should further improve the quality of information disclosure and information transparency, so that external investors can correctly judge and evaluate the intrinsic value of the enterprise, strengthen tolerance for innovation failure, and reduce short term performance pressure on managers

Because this study only focuses on the relationship between analyst optimism bias and RD investment, it has not yet penetrated into the specific performance of its performance enhancing pressure mechanism, that is, the mechanism of its action has yet to be further testedTherefore, follow-up research can be carried out from the perspective of the impact path of analysts' optimistic bias on corporate RD investment

 

Key words: analyst optimism bias; RD investment; conflict of interest; transparency of information

Views[ Share: Weibo WeChat Q-zone